Fortunately I work for a company that is witnessing amazing growth. And with tremendous growth comes a lot of interviewing. Last week alone I interviewed ten separate folks for four different positions. During each interview I like to examine how I performed; the questions asked, the information given, how much data I truly feel I got out of the person. Proper interviewing is certainly more art than science and over the years I’ve learned a great deal from those around me on how to get what you need when interviewing a person for a position.
Mix It Up
One of the most simple steps you can take is to mix up the people who will be conducting the interview. This is particularly important when interviewing marketing personnel, but it can also bring a fresh perspective to any role you are trying to fill. Many of the folks who came in to interview last week met with a variety of people outside of the marketing department, including our CTO. Obviously everyone in the company has a stake in who gets hired, no matter the position, but I often get the best opinions on a candidate from those outside of the marketing realm. These people know what is needed, but they can also remove any potential bias they may have about marketing talents and really cut to the core of the candidate as an overall talent. Just last week my CTO provided me with some terrific interview questions based on his conversations with a candidate. Make sure you include people outside of your own department in the interview process, it will open up your eyes to the strengths and weaknesses of a candidate.
Go Back For More
Traditionally people usually have one or two rounds of interviews and then make a decision. That seems a bit brash for someone that you’ll be spending 50-60 hours with a week, don’t you think? Would you get engaged after the second date? Don’t be afraid of having an extended interview process that could be 3-5 rounds. They don’t have to be all marathon-day sessions with multiple people, but it is good to get in front of a person several times to get a sense of when they are being a “job candidate” and when they are being themselves. Set up an initial phone screen, follow it up with an interview session with the marketing team, bring them back in for the interviews with folks outside of your team and then maybe close it up with a one-on-one session. Over time you will get a good handle on the different “flavors” of the candidate, their ability to schedule time into their calendar, attention to detail on how they remember items over a period of time and more opportunities to get to know this person you are about to spend so much time with over the coming months.
Spice Up The Locale
OK, I’m taking the “work relationship” metaphor too far, but what I mean is that you should interview the person at least once outside of your own offices. Personally I like to use the coffee shop across the street, especially for the first interview. There are many reasons for this including:
- Introduction–Did they do their homework and connect with me on LinkedIn, hence they know what my ugly mug looks like?
- Manners–How do they treat the folks working at the coffee shop?
- Personality–Out of the office, but still in a business-like setting, can they relax a bit and let out their personality?
I posed this question on Twitter and Jim Storer had an interesting suggestion, get the candidate on the golf course and you’ll learn a bunch of things:

Certainly a bit more intense than the coffee shop, but I think Jim would agree that one of the reasons the golf course works is because it is outside of the office space. Our friend Natayna Anderson had a good point of course, not everyone plays golf, but again I do think one could find a setting that would truly place a candidate out of their element and provide you with a much deeper understanding of their skill set.
Be Consistent
Asking the same exact question every single time is not only boring, but will also not give you a fair representation of different people. However, it is important to have some benchmark questions to ask each candidate, even if you tailor them to their personality or the flow of the conversation. The reason is obvious, you need to have easy ways to compare and contrast candidates. This becomes even more important when comparing two very strong candidates, providing you with a potentially tie-breaking formula.
Put Them To The Test
Some people are just really, really good at interviewing. You know who I’m talking about. Perhaps you are one of those people. But guess what those people can’t do, handle a challenging test. Don’t feel like you can’t tax your candidate with homework. A few suggestions, again from the marketing world:
- Rewrite the company boilerplate using all the information at your disposal.
- Provide a 90-day demand generation plan.
- Write a post for the company blog.
- Detail the five things you believe our competitors do better than us.
The ultimate lesson in interviewing is to be hard on the candidate, because their job is going to be hard.
Mix it up with the people interviewing, because they will have to have relationships with multitudes of co-workers.
Take them out of their element, it will provide a small light into their personality.
And don’t be afraid to ask for more, because the person who goes above and beyond is the person you’ll want to keep.